As sure as we are that the sun will appear each morning, we are just as certain that the next mass shooting is coming soon. And in what may be the perfect symmetry of irresponsibility, many of the very same people who have prevented a rational response to our public health crisis of gun violence are also leading the charge to undermine the sysyem of taxation that has provided the funds to make America great. Irony intended.
The common thread through these two self-defeating approaches to important public policy issues is a narrow focus on self-interest and a rejection of any sense of the common good. A proto-typical Second Amendment advocate argues some version of: “My God-given right to own and carry whatever weapon of deadly violence I choose is more important than any right you may assert. As far as I’m concerned, the Second Amendment is the only section of the U.S. Constitution that matters. And it is the only clause that should be seen as absolute without any limits or qualifications.”
A non-Muslim, non-foreign terrorist with a gun unleashed the most recent round of carnage in Santa Fe, Texas on Friday. The same can be said about Parkland, Florida, Charleston, South Carolina and lots of other mass shootings. The Texas assassin didn’t need to climb over or dig under a wall. He didn’t need to take advantage of some loophole in the immigration sysyem. All he needed to do—and it was incredibly easy—was to grab the guns that his father had purchased legally but had failed to secure in a safe place. Shouldn’t people who are so careless with guns be criminally liable?
What is stupid, irresponsible and stunning is that we have a clear list of things we could do to reduce gun violence in this country if only we had the courage to act. There are no perfect solutions, no fail-safe remedies, but we sure could do better. It is a national disgrace, though apparently not an embarrassment to Second Amendment absolutists, that we don’t.
The Republican Party in almost its entirety is a group of craven cowards. They are petrified by the fear of the NRA’s supposed political might and indebted to its campaign contributions. Since rational discourse is totally ineffective, the only appropriate response is to vote as many of them out of office as possible.
Meanwhile, President Trump can’t even muster an ounce of genuine sympathy for the victims of gun violence. He moves onto the next subject so quickly that you’re not even sure he has uttered pious words about “thoughts and prayers” for the families. Trump deserves the same fate as the congressional members of what once was a party of honorable and decent people.
Trump is trying to destroy American government as if it was an alien being. If you’ve haven’t read it yet, take a look at Evan Osnos’ recent article in The New Yorker, “Only the Best People.” He describes in chilling detail how Trump is dismantling one agency after another and driving loyal American civil servants away. Similarly, his executive order attacking Planned Parenthood and his rejection of scientific research about climate change are at their base efforts to prevent people from speaking the truth.
Trump’s attack on the role of government builds on the foundation of those who have been arguing for years about the evils of taxation. Oliver Wendell Holmes famously said a century ago that taxes are the price we pay for a civilized society. Government funds allowed us to build the massive infrastructure that has been the literal backbone of the country as well as the catalyst for much of our economic growth. Do you remember the debate during the 2012 presidential campaign about whether captains of industry built their fortunes entirely on their own? Barack Obama was correct then and he still is that it requires a partnership.
Much of the anti-tax movement is about greed, pure and simple. And it’s been working incredibly effectively, as the increased concentration of wealth at the very top vividly demonstrates. But accumulation of riches by the 1% apparently hasn’t been enough as the unseemly rush to enact another Republican tax law earlier this year attests.
Meanwhile, basic services of government at the state and local levels are stretched to the breaking point—decaying infrastructure, out-of-date school textbooks, potholes that go unrepaired. Federal officials, citing inadequate revenues—the direct consequence of tax cuts—increase the rent of people in public housing, hollow out the State Department, drive up the cost of health insurance even as many lose their coverage and talk ominously of needing to reduce Social Security and Medicare benefits in order to “balance the budget.”
The ugly truth is that the American social contract is unraveling before our eyes. Even though we can’t yet see the full extent of the damage being done by Trump and his co-conspirators, “We the People” is turning into Us and Them. A refusal to tax ourselves for the things that will make us a better country and will enable everyone to have a share, if only a small one, is both a cause and a symptom. The unwillingness to enact obvious remedies to the epidemic of gun violence that every other civilized nation in the world has seen as unacceptable is the other bookend of our malaise.
Those aren’t our only serious problems and, in fact, should be easier to deal with than some of our other challenges such as race relations. As one of the songs in the hit musical “Hamilton” puts it, “Oceans rise, Empires fall.” That about says it all.